Who will defend dog owners like me?
This is the title of an article written by Allison Pearson in the Daily Telegraph in which she describes several experiences recounted by dog owners, including her, about the fear and apprehension they experience when out walking their dogs. She details, in particular, an attack on a dog by 10 other dogs that were all off lead. She includes comment from a dog behaviourist and bemoans, quite rightly the lack of redress available for dogs attacking other dogs.
This highlights a marked change in the dog owning society at large but one that has been coming for quite a long time. All the signs are there and have been for over 10 years and like so many pressure cookers, they take time to build up to bursting point and this pressure cooker is just starting to get warm.
Attitudes to dogs have changed and yes there a minority of dogs used as protection or weapons that are a deliberate threat to society. The rest, however, are a product of our society. I am not going on to talk about the lack of discipline in homes and schools, even though this can be a factor. No, I am going to talk about the ridiculous farce that represents dog training in this country as it is this which sets the expectations and standards that we are now starting to see the consequences of in adult dogs.
Firstly, some information about me. so you can understand how and why I have arrived at these conclusions. I am a professional dog behaviourist and have been for 19 years. I am also a professional dog trainer and those two disciplines are entirely different yet one directly affects the other and this is why the two must be combined in order to have a well-behaved dog. I work with challenging dogs. Very often these dogs have been kicked out of your typical dog training class because they are disruptive. I work with dogs that are aggressive, both to dogs and to people, I work with dogs the courts have classified as dangerous and I work with these dogs in a class environment. I successfully retrain these dogs to be well-behaved members of society.
In Allison’s article the biggest problem is dogs who are out of control when off the lead and how these dogs think they can behave when off the lead, especially around other dogs. Now, you might think this is a problem with aggressive adult dogs and whilst that is when these behaviours are displayed, their root cause goes much further back. The root causes of these behaviours stem from puppyhood and the “socialization” the dog gets as a puppy. The biggest problem with puppy socialization is that it is decided by people what is best for a puppy and this is why it sets a bad example for the puppy.
People are under the impression a puppy should be encouraged to meet every dog it sees and every person it sees as this is “socializing” the puppy. That is an incredible belief yet you see it on every park and open space in the country. What is worse is you see it in almost every dog training school in the country as well.
So why is this a bad thing? It is a bad thing because it does not take into account how the puppy is feeling or thinking and, it sets a very dangerous perception in the puppy. Let me ask you this. Do you want to meet every person you see? Did you like every one you were at school with? Do you like everyone you work with? Do you like all of your neighbours?
So why do you think your puppy will want to meet every dog it sees and every person? Do you think if the puppy was still with its mother that she would let other dogs get very close to her puppies? Or do you think she would ensure they are safe and protected and trust her to look after them?
Most people would not let a toddler go and play with older kids unsupervised if they didn’t know them yet we do exactly this with our dogs. All this teaches our dogs is they have to fend for themselves and that we, as owners, do not want to look after them and do not want to be involved in their upbringing.
Most dogs find this whole experience very frightening, puppies very often are forced to show submissive behaviours to older dogs when they meet because this is the only way they can prevent the older dog beating them up. The more often this is repeated, the worse the fear grows in the puppy. As the puppy grows and gains confidence, and this is especially relevant in Terrier breeds, they start to resent having to submit and they decide to take a stand. When anyone stands up to a bully, it takes courage and strength, it is also mixed with a healthy dose of fear so when the dog takes this stand, the barking is rapid, the body is stiff and the posture is aggressive.
The human reaction to this “sudden” change in behaviour is usually “Where did that come form? They have always been fine with other dogs.” Then the barking dog receives a royal telling off, which in reality only fuels the behaviour. So now the dog has associated a fear based behaviour towards other dogs and this has been reinforced by the owner, the dog now believes it has to apply this to every dog it sees and when it does, the behaviour again generates a big reaction from the owner and so the behaviour builds and builds. When a dog like this is off the lead, there is a very good chance it will “attack” other dogs. What it is really doing is making up for all the times the dog was forced to submit, the pent up frustration and anger spills over and he vents this usually in the face of another dog. This either results in the other dog fighting back or trying to run away. It always results in the owners matching the stress in their dogs so everyone and every dog is out of control.
When a group of dogs behave in this way, as Allison has described in her article, serious damage and even death can occur as one dog may defend themselves against one or two other dogs, but if they are up against a large number of dogs they will try and run. If they are caught, like Dozer was, there is little the dog can do against that many attackers.
There is also little anyone can do at the moment against the owner of the 10 dogs despite having 10 dogs off lead over which he had absolutely no control. For this there should be no excuse as the behaviours hos dogs have displayed are entirely allowed by him and even reinforced by him, whether willingly or not is irrelevant.
It is not enough to then try and address the issues these dogs have although they can be retrained, this takes time and dedication from a new owner but that is merely passing the burden of responsibility on to some one else. The onus of responsibility needs to be legally on the owner that they are solely responsible for the behaviour of their dog or dogs. Yes training should be mandatory but given the present state of dog training in this country, I don’t believe that would make any difference. As an aside, in my own dog behaviour classes, I teach dog owners how to deal with approaching, off lead dogs in a safe and controlled way.
Dog owners need to know how to teach their dogs to be well behaved. What do I mean by well behaved? Quite simple really, by well behaved I mean they should know how to walk on a slack lead, they should be calm and relaxed in as many situations as possible and they should come back to you when asked. That is a definition of a well-behaved dog. Is yours?